Vacasa vs Airbnb: What's the Difference and Which Is Better for Your Property?

Vacasa vs Airbnb is a comparison that reveals a common misconception about the short-term rental industry. Airbnb is a booking platform — a marketplace where travelers find and book properties. Vacasa is a management company — an operator that lists and manages your property on Airbnb and other platforms. They're not competing alternatives; they serve fundamentally different functions. But understanding this distinction is essential for any property owner evaluating their options. See Awning's top Airbnb management companies review for a proper management company comparison.

What Airbnb Actually Is

Airbnb is a marketplace. They connect travelers with properties and collect a service fee from both guests and hosts. They don't manage properties — they provide the platform on which properties are listed. As an Airbnb host, you can self-manage your property or hire a management company to manage it on your behalf. Airbnb is just the channel.

As a Property Owner on Airbnb:

•        You (or your manager) create and maintain the listing

•        Airbnb charges you a 3% service fee on each booking

•        Airbnb handles payment processing and some guest protections

•        Everything else — pricing, cleaning, communication, maintenance — is your responsibility

What Vacasa Actually Is

Vacasa is a management company that manages your property on Airbnb, VRBO, Booking.com, and other platforms. They handle operations — pricing, guest communication, cleaning, maintenance — in exchange for a management fee of 25–35% of gross revenue. Your property appears on Airbnb because Vacasa lists it there, not because you signed up with Airbnb directly.

As a Property Owner with Vacasa:

•        Vacasa creates and manages your listing on Airbnb and other channels

•        Vacasa handles pricing, guest communication, cleaning, and maintenance

•        You pay Vacasa 25–35% of gross revenue

•        Vacasa pays Airbnb's 3% host fee from your revenue

The Real Question: Which Channels + Which Manager?

The right framework isn't 'Vacasa vs Airbnb' — it's 'which management approach do I want?' with 'which channels does my manager distribute on?' as a sub-question. Your options:

•        Self-manage on Airbnb (and VRBO, Booking.com, etc.) — no management fee, maximum control, significant time commitment

•        Use a partial-service manager like Evolve — 10% fee, booking management only, you handle local ops

•        Use a full-service manager like Vacasa or Awning — 25–35% fee, everything handled, truly passive

The management company you choose determines which channels your property appears on. The best managers list on Airbnb, VRBO, Booking.com, and 47+ other platforms — maximizing your reach without you managing each channel separately.

Channel Reach: Airbnb Alone vs Multi-Channel

One of the key advantages of using a strong management company: they distribute across far more channels than most self-managers maintain. Awning lists properties on 50+ booking platforms. Self-managing hosts typically use 1–3 channels. Use Awning's income estimator to see the revenue impact of multi-channel distribution on your specific property.

Validate any revenue projection against Airbnb market data before making a management decision.

‍

📎  Related Reading

→ Top Airbnb Management Companies Reviewed

→ Airbnb Income Estimator

→ Airbnb Market Data by City

→ Airbnb Cap Rates Guide

→ Awning Full-Service Management

→ RedAwning Portfolio Management

‍

Get listed on 50+ channels with Awning →