The Pros and Cons of Condo vs. Single-Family Homes for Airbnb Investing

Investing in Airbnb properties can be an exciting way to generate income, but choosing the right type of property is key to maximizing your success. Condos and single-family homes both offer unique advantages, but they come with their own sets of challenges, too. Condos might promise lower maintenance and shared amenities, while single-family homes often offer more space and flexibility.

But which is the better fit for your investment goals? In this article, we’ll explore the pros and cons of each option, breaking down the factors that matter most—like costs, control, location, and rental income potential—so you can make the most informed decision for your Airbnb venture. For more insights on how Airbnb compares to traditional rentals, check out our helpful guide.

1. Initial Purchase and Maintenance Costs

When you’re weighing the initial costs of buying a condo versus a single-family home, there’s a noticeable difference right off the bat.

Condos generally come with a lower purchase price, which is a nice plus if you’re looking to start with a smaller investment. But there's a catch: HOA fees. These fees are paid monthly or annually to cover the maintenance of shared spaces like hallways, pools, and any on-site amenities. While these can reduce your personal upkeep, they do impact your overall cash flow and need to be considered as part of your monthly expenses.

Single-Family Homes, on the other hand, come with a higher upfront price, but here, you won’t be dealing with HOA fees. Instead, you’re responsible for all maintenance and repairs yourself—from landscaping to the roof. This flexibility is a perk for some investors, but it does mean your expenses can vary.

Key Consideration: HOA fees can cut into your rental profits, so factor them into your cash flow projections. That way, you’re clear on how these costs will affect your bottom line over time.

2. Control and Flexibility

When it comes to control and flexibility, condos and single-family homes are like night and day.

One of the biggest considerations with condos is the homeowners association (HOA). HOAs often have strict rules about short-term rentals. You might face restrictions on the number of days you can rent out your place, or even need to get permission each time you list it on Airbnb. They may also have guidelines on things like noise levels, guest behavior, and common area usage, which can limit how you run your rental. While these rules can keep things organized and pleasant for everyone in the building, they also reduce your flexibility as an owner.

On the other hand, owning a single-family home means you’re the boss. Without an HOA to answer to, you can make decisions about your property with much more freedom. Want to add some cool amenities to make your listing stand out? Go for it. Need to make last-minute changes to your rental terms? No problem. This level of control can be a big advantage, especially if you want to tailor the property to specific guest needs or trends in the market.

Key Consideration: Think about how much control matters to you. If you want the freedom to manage every detail of your rental and adapt quickly to guest expectations, a single-family home might be a better fit. However, if you’re okay with some rules in exchange for less property upkeep, a condo with HOA oversight could still work. It all comes down to how hands-on you want to be with your investment and your vision for the space.

3. Location and Amenities

When it comes to location and amenities, condos and single-family homes offer distinctly different advantages for Airbnb hosts.

If you’re drawn to the energy of urban hotspots or high-demand tourist areas, condos might be your perfect fit. These properties are often nestled in city centers or bustling neighborhoods, giving guests easy access to attractions, dining, and shopping. Plus, condos frequently come with built-in perks like pools, fitness centers, and even security, all of which are huge selling points for travelers. The convenience of these amenities can be a magnet for guests looking for a “turnkey” experience — just bring your suitcase and dive into relaxation.

On the flip side, single-family homes tend to offer more room to breathe — literally. With extra space, yards, and greater privacy, these properties are a favorite for families, larger groups, and guests who appreciate a bit more elbow room. The amenities vary by property, so while one home might have a cozy backyard for evening barbecues, another could offer multiple bedrooms or a private pool, making it ideal for families or group vacations.

Key Consideration: The location and amenities you offer can be powerful factors in attracting guests and keeping your Airbnb booked. Condos offer the buzz and convenience of city life, while single-family homes appeal to those looking for privacy and space. Think about the type of guest you want to attract, and consider which property type best meets their needs.

4. Rental Income Potential

When it comes to rental income, both condos and single-family homes bring unique advantages to the table.

Condos often come with slightly lower nightly rates. This might sound like a drawback at first, but condos can be located in vibrant urban areas or resort-like complexes, making them highly appealing to guests who want easy access to amenities like pools, gyms, and city attractions. This prime location and convenience can lead to a high occupancy rate, which helps offset those lower nightly prices and keeps revenue steady.

On the flip side, Single-Family Homes tend to command higher nightly rates due to their space and privacy—big draws for families or groups traveling together. They also offer more potential for appreciation in value over time, making them a solid choice if you’re looking to build long-term wealth in addition to rental income.

Key Consideration: Think about what works best for your investment style—are you aiming for high occupancy with a steady stream of bookings, or are you more interested in charging a premium for space and privacy? Each property type shapes your potential revenue and growth differently, so consider which option aligns with your goals.

5. Management and Maintenance

With a condo, much of the routine maintenance is handled by the homeowners association (HOA), covering things like landscaping, exterior repairs, and common area upkeep. This setup can be a relief for busy investors since there’s less hands-on management involved. However, condo living also means sharing walls and common spaces with neighbors, which can sometimes lead to noise complaints or guest restrictions imposed by the HOA. If you’re okay with a little less control over the immediate environment, condos can offer a lower-stress approach to property maintenance.

Owning a single-family home comes with full responsibility for maintenance, from lawn care to fixing that leaky faucet. While this requires a bit more time and investment, it also offers something condo owners often envy: privacy. Single-family homes allow guests to enjoy their stay without close neighbors, which can enhance the guest experience, particularly for families or groups looking for a quieter, more private space. For many Airbnb hosts, the extra work is worth it for the added flexibility and guest satisfaction.

Key Consideration: Think about how much time and energy you’re willing to spend on upkeep. If you want a hands-off approach, a condo might suit you better; if maximizing guest satisfaction is your goal, the privacy of a single-family home could be ideal.

6. Financing and Insurance

Financing a condo can sometimes be trickier than financing a single-family home, especially if the condo’s homeowners association (HOA) has strict guidelines or the association’s finances aren’t in top shape. Lenders often look closely at the HOA’s financial health since it affects property values. The upside? Condo insurance costs are generally lower because the HOA’s insurance often covers the building structure, so owners only need to insure the interior and their personal belongings.

Financing for single-family homes is typically more straightforward, with fewer hurdles related to associations or shared financial responsibility. However, owners will need full insurance coverage for the entire property, including both the structure and its contents. While this comprehensive insurance provides peace of mind, it does come with a higher price tag than condo insurance.

Key Consideration: Whether you’re eyeing a condo or a single-family home, consider how financing and insurance costs will affect your cash flow. Understanding these expenses upfront can help ensure you’re prepared for what each option entails in terms of both cost and risk.

To Sum

Both condos and single-family homes have unique advantages and challenges for Airbnb investing. Condos often offer lower costs and attractive amenities but may come with HOA restrictions. Single-family homes offer more flexibility and privacy, which can lead to higher nightly rates but also involve more maintenance responsibilities.

Ultimately, choosing the right property type comes down to your personal investment goals—whether it’s maximizing income, minimizing management, or enjoying long-term appreciation. Take time to assess what’s most important for your Airbnb venture.

If you’re ready to invest, Awning’s experts are here to help you find, furnish, and manage the perfect Airbnb property. Check out Awning’s services to get started with a team that has your success in mind!

‍