Sonder vs Vacasa: Two Very Different Short-Term Rental Models Compared

Sonder and Vacasa are both major players in the short-term rental space — but they operate on fundamentally different business models. Understanding this distinction is essential before deciding how to position your property or where to invest. See Awning's top Airbnb management companies review for the broader management company landscape.

Sonder: The Master Lease Model

Sonder doesn't manage your property for a fee — they lease it from you directly and operate it as part of their inventory. You receive a fixed rent payment regardless of occupancy; Sonder keeps all revenue above that. They handle everything: furnishing, operations, staffing, and guest experience. Properties are branded and operated under the Sonder name.

Sonder's Model: What It Means for Property Owners

•        You receive guaranteed rent — no occupancy risk

•        You give up all upside if the property performs above the lease rate

•        Sonder controls the guest experience and property presentation

•        Lease terms typically 3–5 years — you're locked in

•        Sonder has gone through significant financial turbulence — evaluate their stability before committing

Who Sonder's Model Works For:

•        Owners who prioritize income stability over upside

•        Investors with multiple units who want zero operational involvement

•        Urban condo or apartment owners in markets where Sonder actively leases

Vacasa: The Traditional Management Fee Model

Vacasa manages your property for a commission (25–35% of gross revenue) while you retain ownership and capture all revenue upside above the fee. Vacasa handles operations, but you remain the property owner with all associated rights and obligations.

Vacasa's Model: What It Means for Property Owners

•        You keep all revenue upside as the property owner

•        You bear occupancy risk — slow months mean lower income

•        Vacasa manages operations but you own the relationship with the asset

•        More flexibility to switch managers or self-manage in the future

The Key Distinction: Lease vs Management

If a property owner is evaluating Sonder vs Vacasa, the real question is: do you want guaranteed income with no upside, or variable income with full upside? This isn't a service quality comparison — it's a fundamental business model decision.

Sonder's guaranteed lease model is attractive in concept but comes with meaningful risk: Sonder has faced serious financial challenges. Before signing a multi-year lease, research their current financial health and local market presence carefully.

What the Data Says About Each Market

Before choosing either model, understand your market's revenue potential. Awning's Airbnb market data shows occupancy rates and ADR for comparable properties — this tells you whether Sonder's lease offer represents fair value or is significantly below market. The Airbnb income estimator projects your potential revenue under a traditional management model.

For investment underwriting, see Awning's Airbnb cap rate guide. For financing, see Airbnb loan options.

‍

📎  Related Reading

→ Top Airbnb Management Companies Reviewed

→ Airbnb Market Data — Know Your Numbers

→ Airbnb Income Estimator

→ Airbnb Cap Rates

→ Awning Full-Service Management

‍

Explore traditional management with Awning →